Any good results from SegNet?

[farnaznouraei]

I wanted to ask if anyone has tested SegNet implementation on Pascal VOC 2012 and has gotten good results? I even trained it for only 20 images and still get very bad results (almost worse than random guessing) on the same training images! The loss never goes lower than 200000 and oscillates a lot.

My config file:

# Model Configuration
model:
  arch: segnet

# Data Configuration
data:
  dataset: pascal
  train_split: train
  val_split: val
  img_rows: 318
  img_cols: 500
  path: /home/ubuntu/data/VOC/VOCdevkit/VOC2012
  sbd_path: /home/ubuntu/data/VOC/benchmark_RELEASE/

# Training Configuration
training:
  n_workers: 1
  train_iters: 1000
  batch_size: 1
  val_interval: 3000
  print_interval: 30
  loss:
    name: 'cross_entropy'
    size_average: False
    
# Optmizer Configuration
optimizer:
    name: 'adam'
    lr: 1.0e-4

# LR Schedule Configuration
lr_schedule:
  #name: constant_lr
momentum: 0.99
weight_decay: 0.0005


# Resume from checkpoint  
resume: null

[alexanderuo]

me too.my config file is :
model: arch: fcn8s data: dataset: nyuv2 train_split: training val_split: val img_rows: 480 img_cols: 640 path: /users/guozibin/dukaiyang/2.9k/dataset/input sbd_path: /private/home/meetshah/datasets/VOC/benchmark_RELEASE/ training: train_iters: 100000 batch_size: 1 val_interval: 1000 n_workers: 16 print_interval: 50 optimizer: name: 'sgd' lr: 1.0e-10 weight_decay: 0.0005 momentum: 0.99 loss: name: 'cross_entropy' size_average: False lr_schedule: resume: fcn8s_pascal_best_model.pkl

[farnaznouraei]

@alexanderuo The Pascal data loader in this repo has a lot of issues. Most important one being that the resize function generates unwanted values in the label masks. I made some changes and made it work:

`
import os
from os.path import join as pjoin
import collections
import json
import torch
import numpy as np
import scipy.io as io
import matplotlib.pyplot as plt
import glob
import cv2

from PIL import Image
from tqdm import tqdm
from torch.utils import data as dt
from torchvision import transforms
import warnings

class pascalVOCLoader(dt.Dataset):
"""Data loader for the Pascal VOC semantic segmentation dataset.

Annotations from both the original VOC data (which consist of RGB images
in which colours map to specific classes) and the SBD (Berkely) dataset
(where annotations are stored as .mat files) are converted into a common
`label_mask` format.  Under this format, each mask is an (M,N) array of
integer values from 0 to 21, where 0 represents the background class.

The label masks are stored in a new folder, called `pre_encoded`, which
is added as a subdirectory of the `SegmentationClass` folder in the
original Pascal VOC data layout.

A total of four data splits are provided for working with the VOC data:
    train: The original VOC 2012 training data - 1464 images
    val: The original VOC 2012 validation data - 1449 images
    train_aug: The unique images present in both the train split and
               training images from SBD: - 8829 images (the unique members
               of the result of combining lists of length 1464 and 8498)
    test: an arbitrary set of images from the "val" set, written in a text file test.txt in the same directory
"""

def __init__(
    self,
    root="/gpfs/home/fnouraei/data/fnouraei/VOC/VOCdevkit/VOC2012/", # choose your main path as default
    sbd_path="/gpfs/home/fnouraei/data/fnouraei/VOC/benchmark_RELEASE", # choose your SBD dir as default
    split="train", # {"train", "val", "test", "train_aug"}
    is_transform=True,
    img_size=(128,128), # choose INPUT_SIZE as default
    augmentations=None,
    img_norm=True,
    aug_with_sbd = False, # choose whether or not to add Berkeley images to val and train sets by default
):
    self.root = root
    self.sbd_path = sbd_path
    self.aug_with_sbd = aug_with_sbd
    self.split = split
    self.is_transform = is_transform
    self.augmentations = augmentations
    self.img_norm = img_norm
    self.n_classes = 21
    self.mean = np.array([104.00699, 116.66877, 122.67892])
    self.files = collections.defaultdict(list)
    self.img_size = img_size if isinstance(img_size, tuple) else (img_size, img_size)

    
    for split in ["train", "val", "test"]:
        path = pjoin(self.root, "ImageSets","Segmentation", split + ".txt")
        file_list = tuple(open(path, "r"))
        file_list = [id_.rstrip() for id_ in file_list]
        self.files[split] = file_list
    self.setup_annotations()
    
    if not self.img_norm:
        self.tf = transforms.ToTensor()
    else: 
        self.tf = transforms.Compose(
            [
            
                transforms.ToTensor()
                ,transforms.Normalize([0.485, 0.456, 0.406], [0.229, 0.224, 0.225])
            ])



def __len__(self):
    return len(self.files[self.split])

def __getitem__(self, index):
    
    im_name = self.files[self.split][index]
    im_path = pjoin(self.root, "JPEGImages", im_name + ".jpg")
    lbl_path = pjoin(self.root, "SegmentationClass/pre_encoded", im_name + ".png")
    if self.aug_with_sbd: 
        lbl_path = pjoin(self.root, "SegmentationClass/pre_encoded_aug", im_name + ".png")
    im = cv2.imread(im_path, cv2.IMREAD_UNCHANGED)
    im = cv2.cvtColor(np.array(im), cv2.COLOR_BGR2RGB)
    lbl = cv2.imread(lbl_path,  cv2.IMREAD_UNCHANGED)
    

    if self.augmentations is not None:
        im, lbl = self.augmentations(im, lbl)
    if self.is_transform:
        im, lbl = self.transform(im, lbl)
    
    return im, lbl

def transform(self, img, lbl):
    if self.img_size == ("same", "same"):
        pass
    else:
        img = cv2.resize(img, (self.img_size[0], self.img_size[1]), interpolation =cv2.INTER_NEAREST)
        lbl = cv2.resize(lbl, (self.img_size[0], self.img_size[1]), interpolation =cv2.INTER_NEAREST)
    
    
    img = self.tf(img)

    lbl = torch.from_numpy(np.array(lbl)).long()
    lbl[lbl == 255] = 0
    return img, lbl

def get_pascal_labels(self):
    """Load the mapping that associates pascal classes with label colors

    Returns:
        np.ndarray with dimensions (21, 3)
    """
    return np.asarray( [
            [0, 0, 0],        #0: bg
            [128, 0, 0],      #1: aeroplane
            [0, 128, 0],      #2: bicycle   
            [128, 128, 0],    #3: bird  
            [0, 0, 128],      #4: boat  
            [128, 0, 128],    #5: bottle 
            [0, 128, 128],    #6: bus 
            [128, 128, 128],  #7: car 
            [64, 0, 0],       #8: cat
            [192, 0, 0],      #9: chair
            [64, 128, 0],     #10: cow
            [192, 128, 0],    #11: dining table
            [64, 0, 128],     #12: dog
            [192, 0, 128],    #13: horse
            [64, 128, 128],   #14: motorbike 
            [192, 128, 128],  #15: person
            [0, 64, 0],       #16: potted plant
            [128, 64, 0],     #17: sheep
            [0, 192, 0],      #18: sofa
            [128, 192, 0],    #19: train
            [0, 64, 128],     #20: tv/monitor
        ] )
def encode_segmap(self, mask):
    """Encode segmentation label images as pascal classes

    Args:
        mask (np.ndarray): raw segmentation label image of dimension
          (M, N, 3), in which the Pascal classes are encoded as colours.

    Returns:
        (np.ndarray): class map with dimensions (M,N), where the value at
        a given location is the integer denoting the class index.
    """
    mask = mask.astype(int)
    label_mask = np.zeros((mask.shape[0], mask.shape[1]), dtype=np.int16)
    for ii, label in enumerate(self.get_pascal_labels()):
        label_mask[np.where(np.all(mask == label, axis=-1))[:2]] = ii
    label_mask = label_mask.astype(int)

    return label_mask

def decode_segmap(self, label_mask, plot=False):
    """Decode segmentation class labels into a color image

    Args:
        label_mask (np.ndarray): an (M,N) array of integer values denoting
          the class label at each spatial location.
        plot (bool, optional): whether to show the resulting color image
          in a figure.

    Returns:
        (np.ndarray, optional): the resulting decoded color image.
    """
    label_colours = self.get_pascal_labels()
    r = label_mask.copy()
    g = label_mask.copy()
    b = label_mask.copy()
    for ll in range(0, self.n_classes):
        r[label_mask == ll] = label_colours[ll, 0]
        g[label_mask == ll] = label_colours[ll, 1]
        b[label_mask == ll] = label_colours[ll, 2]
    rgb = np.zeros((label_mask.shape[0], label_mask.shape[1], 3))
    rgb[:, :, 0] = r / 255.0
    rgb[:, :, 1] = g / 255.0
    rgb[:, :, 2] = b / 255.0
    if plot:
        plt.imshow(rgb)
        plt.show()
    else:
        return rgb

def setup_annotations(self):
    """
    pre-encode all segmentation labels into the
    common label_mask format (if this has not already been done). 
    """
    sbd_path = self.sbd_path
    if not self.aug_with_sbd:
        target_path = pjoin(self.root, "SegmentationClass/pre_encoded")
    if self.aug_with_sbd:
        target_path = pjoin(self.root, "SegmentationClass/pre_encoded_aug")
        
    if not os.path.exists(target_path):
        os.makedirs(target_path)
    
    path = pjoin(sbd_path, "dataset", "train.txt")
    sbd_train_list = tuple(open(path, "r"))
    sbd_train_list = [id_.rstrip() for id_ in sbd_train_list]
    
    if not self.aug_with_sbd:
        train = self.files["train"]
        
    if self.aug_with_sbd:
        train_aug = self.files["train"] + sbd_train_list
    
    val = self.files["val"]            
    test = self.files["test"]
    
    if self.aug_with_sbd:
        # keep unique elements (stable)
        train_aug = [train_aug[i] for i in sorted(np.unique(train_aug, return_index=True)[1])]
        self.files["train_aug"] = train_aug
    
    pre_encoded = glob.glob(pjoin(target_path, "*.png"))
    
    if not self.aug_with_sbd:
        expected = len(list(set().union(val,test,train)))
        # make sure validation set is held out
        #print("[Debug] val and train intersection: ", len(list(set().intersection(val,train))))
    else:
        expected = len(list(set().union(val,test,train_aug)))
        # make sure validation set is held out
        #print("[Debug] val and train intersection: ", len(list(set().intersection(val,train_aug))))
        

    if len(pre_encoded) < expected: 
        
        if self.aug_with_sbd:
            for ii in tqdm(sbd_train_list, desc="pre-encode SBD"):
                fname = ii + ".png"
                lbl_path = pjoin(sbd_path, "dataset/cls", ii + ".mat")
                data = io.loadmat(lbl_path)
                lbl = data["GTcls"][0]["Segmentation"][0].astype(np.int32)      
                if not os.path.exists(pjoin(target_path, fname)):
                    cv2.imwrite(pjoin(target_path, fname), lbl)

        
        for split in ["train", "val", "test"]:
        
            for ii in tqdm(self.files[split], desc="pre-encode "+split):
                fname = ii + ".png"
                lbl_path = pjoin(self.root, "SegmentationClass", fname)
                lbl = cv2.imread(lbl_path,  cv2.IMREAD_UNCHANGED)
                lbl = cv2.cvtColor(np.array(lbl), cv2.COLOR_BGR2RGB) 
                lbl = self.encode_segmap(lbl)
                #print("[Debug] pre-encoded label before saving as png: ", np.unique(lbl))
                if not os.path.exists(pjoin(target_path, fname)):
                    cv2.imwrite(pjoin(target_path, fname), lbl)

            
    pre_encoded = glob.glob(pjoin(target_path, "*.png"))
    
    print("[info] num expected labels: {}  num pre-encoded labels: {}".format(expected,len(pre_encoded)))

`

I added a pull request to the repo. For the time being, hope this helps!

[GrenRadon]

@alexanderuo The Pascal data loader in this repo has a lot of issues. Most important one being that the resize function generates unwanted values in the label masks. I made some changes and made it work:

` import os from os.path import join as pjoin import collections import json import torch import numpy as np import scipy.io as io import matplotlib.pyplot as plt import glob import cv2

from PIL import Image from tqdm import tqdm from torch.utils import data as dt from torchvision import transforms import warnings

class pascalVOCLoader(dt.Dataset): """Data loader for the Pascal VOC semantic segmentation dataset.

Annotations from both the original VOC data (which consist of RGB images
in which colours map to specific classes) and the SBD (Berkely) dataset
(where annotations are stored as .mat files) are converted into a common
`label_mask` format.  Under this format, each mask is an (M,N) array of
integer values from 0 to 21, where 0 represents the background class.

The label masks are stored in a new folder, called `pre_encoded`, which
is added as a subdirectory of the `SegmentationClass` folder in the
original Pascal VOC data layout.

A total of four data splits are provided for working with the VOC data:
    train: The original VOC 2012 training data - 1464 images
    val: The original VOC 2012 validation data - 1449 images
    train_aug: The unique images present in both the train split and
               training images from SBD: - 8829 images (the unique members
               of the result of combining lists of length 1464 and 8498)
    test: an arbitrary set of images from the "val" set, written in a text file test.txt in the same directory
"""

def __init__(
    self,
    root="/gpfs/home/fnouraei/data/fnouraei/VOC/VOCdevkit/VOC2012/", # choose your main path as default
    sbd_path="/gpfs/home/fnouraei/data/fnouraei/VOC/benchmark_RELEASE", # choose your SBD dir as default
    split="train", # {"train", "val", "test", "train_aug"}
    is_transform=True,
    img_size=(128,128), # choose INPUT_SIZE as default
    augmentations=None,
    img_norm=True,
    aug_with_sbd = False, # choose whether or not to add Berkeley images to val and train sets by default
):
    self.root = root
    self.sbd_path = sbd_path
    self.aug_with_sbd = aug_with_sbd
    self.split = split
    self.is_transform = is_transform
    self.augmentations = augmentations
    self.img_norm = img_norm
    self.n_classes = 21
    self.mean = np.array([104.00699, 116.66877, 122.67892])
    self.files = collections.defaultdict(list)
    self.img_size = img_size if isinstance(img_size, tuple) else (img_size, img_size)

    
    for split in ["train", "val", "test"]:
        path = pjoin(self.root, "ImageSets","Segmentation", split + ".txt")
        file_list = tuple(open(path, "r"))
        file_list = [id_.rstrip() for id_ in file_list]
        self.files[split] = file_list
    self.setup_annotations()
    
    if not self.img_norm:
        self.tf = transforms.ToTensor()
    else: 
        self.tf = transforms.Compose(
            [
            
                transforms.ToTensor()
                ,transforms.Normalize([0.485, 0.456, 0.406], [0.229, 0.224, 0.225])
            ])



def __len__(self):
    return len(self.files[self.split])

def __getitem__(self, index):
    
    im_name = self.files[self.split][index]
    im_path = pjoin(self.root, "JPEGImages", im_name + ".jpg")
    lbl_path = pjoin(self.root, "SegmentationClass/pre_encoded", im_name + ".png")
    if self.aug_with_sbd: 
        lbl_path = pjoin(self.root, "SegmentationClass/pre_encoded_aug", im_name + ".png")
    im = cv2.imread(im_path, cv2.IMREAD_UNCHANGED)
    im = cv2.cvtColor(np.array(im), cv2.COLOR_BGR2RGB)
    lbl = cv2.imread(lbl_path,  cv2.IMREAD_UNCHANGED)
    

    if self.augmentations is not None:
        im, lbl = self.augmentations(im, lbl)
    if self.is_transform:
        im, lbl = self.transform(im, lbl)
    
    return im, lbl

def transform(self, img, lbl):
    if self.img_size == ("same", "same"):
        pass
    else:
        img = cv2.resize(img, (self.img_size[0], self.img_size[1]), interpolation =cv2.INTER_NEAREST)
        lbl = cv2.resize(lbl, (self.img_size[0], self.img_size[1]), interpolation =cv2.INTER_NEAREST)
    
    
    img = self.tf(img)

    lbl = torch.from_numpy(np.array(lbl)).long()
    lbl[lbl == 255] = 0
    return img, lbl

def get_pascal_labels(self):
    """Load the mapping that associates pascal classes with label colors

    Returns:
        np.ndarray with dimensions (21, 3)
    """
    return np.asarray( [
            [0, 0, 0],        #0: bg
            [128, 0, 0],      #1: aeroplane
            [0, 128, 0],      #2: bicycle   
            [128, 128, 0],    #3: bird  
            [0, 0, 128],      #4: boat  
            [128, 0, 128],    #5: bottle 
            [0, 128, 128],    #6: bus 
            [128, 128, 128],  #7: car 
            [64, 0, 0],       #8: cat
            [192, 0, 0],      #9: chair
            [64, 128, 0],     #10: cow
            [192, 128, 0],    #11: dining table
            [64, 0, 128],     #12: dog
            [192, 0, 128],    #13: horse
            [64, 128, 128],   #14: motorbike 
            [192, 128, 128],  #15: person
            [0, 64, 0],       #16: potted plant
            [128, 64, 0],     #17: sheep
            [0, 192, 0],      #18: sofa
            [128, 192, 0],    #19: train
            [0, 64, 128],     #20: tv/monitor
        ] )
def encode_segmap(self, mask):
    """Encode segmentation label images as pascal classes

    Args:
        mask (np.ndarray): raw segmentation label image of dimension
          (M, N, 3), in which the Pascal classes are encoded as colours.

    Returns:
        (np.ndarray): class map with dimensions (M,N), where the value at
        a given location is the integer denoting the class index.
    """
    mask = mask.astype(int)
    label_mask = np.zeros((mask.shape[0], mask.shape[1]), dtype=np.int16)
    for ii, label in enumerate(self.get_pascal_labels()):
        label_mask[np.where(np.all(mask == label, axis=-1))[:2]] = ii
    label_mask = label_mask.astype(int)

    return label_mask

def decode_segmap(self, label_mask, plot=False):
    """Decode segmentation class labels into a color image

    Args:
        label_mask (np.ndarray): an (M,N) array of integer values denoting
          the class label at each spatial location.
        plot (bool, optional): whether to show the resulting color image
          in a figure.

    Returns:
        (np.ndarray, optional): the resulting decoded color image.
    """
    label_colours = self.get_pascal_labels()
    r = label_mask.copy()
    g = label_mask.copy()
    b = label_mask.copy()
    for ll in range(0, self.n_classes):
        r[label_mask == ll] = label_colours[ll, 0]
        g[label_mask == ll] = label_colours[ll, 1]
        b[label_mask == ll] = label_colours[ll, 2]
    rgb = np.zeros((label_mask.shape[0], label_mask.shape[1], 3))
    rgb[:, :, 0] = r / 255.0
    rgb[:, :, 1] = g / 255.0
    rgb[:, :, 2] = b / 255.0
    if plot:
        plt.imshow(rgb)
        plt.show()
    else:
        return rgb

def setup_annotations(self):
    """
    pre-encode all segmentation labels into the
    common label_mask format (if this has not already been done). 
    """
    sbd_path = self.sbd_path
    if not self.aug_with_sbd:
        target_path = pjoin(self.root, "SegmentationClass/pre_encoded")
    if self.aug_with_sbd:
        target_path = pjoin(self.root, "SegmentationClass/pre_encoded_aug")
        
    if not os.path.exists(target_path):
        os.makedirs(target_path)
    
    path = pjoin(sbd_path, "dataset", "train.txt")
    sbd_train_list = tuple(open(path, "r"))
    sbd_train_list = [id_.rstrip() for id_ in sbd_train_list]
    
    if not self.aug_with_sbd:
        train = self.files["train"]
        
    if self.aug_with_sbd:
        train_aug = self.files["train"] + sbd_train_list
    
    val = self.files["val"]            
    test = self.files["test"]
    
    if self.aug_with_sbd:
        # keep unique elements (stable)
        train_aug = [train_aug[i] for i in sorted(np.unique(train_aug, return_index=True)[1])]
        self.files["train_aug"] = train_aug
    
    pre_encoded = glob.glob(pjoin(target_path, "*.png"))
    
    if not self.aug_with_sbd:
        expected = len(list(set().union(val,test,train)))
        # make sure validation set is held out
        #print("[Debug] val and train intersection: ", len(list(set().intersection(val,train))))
    else:
        expected = len(list(set().union(val,test,train_aug)))
        # make sure validation set is held out
        #print("[Debug] val and train intersection: ", len(list(set().intersection(val,train_aug))))
        

    if len(pre_encoded) < expected: 
        
        if self.aug_with_sbd:
            for ii in tqdm(sbd_train_list, desc="pre-encode SBD"):
                fname = ii + ".png"
                lbl_path = pjoin(sbd_path, "dataset/cls", ii + ".mat")
                data = io.loadmat(lbl_path)
                lbl = data["GTcls"][0]["Segmentation"][0].astype(np.int32)      
                if not os.path.exists(pjoin(target_path, fname)):
                    cv2.imwrite(pjoin(target_path, fname), lbl)

        
        for split in ["train", "val", "test"]:
        
            for ii in tqdm(self.files[split], desc="pre-encode "+split):
                fname = ii + ".png"
                lbl_path = pjoin(self.root, "SegmentationClass", fname)
                lbl = cv2.imread(lbl_path,  cv2.IMREAD_UNCHANGED)
                lbl = cv2.cvtColor(np.array(lbl), cv2.COLOR_BGR2RGB) 
                lbl = self.encode_segmap(lbl)
                #print("[Debug] pre-encoded label before saving as png: ", np.unique(lbl))
                if not os.path.exists(pjoin(target_path, fname)):
                    cv2.imwrite(pjoin(target_path, fname), lbl)

            
    pre_encoded = glob.glob(pjoin(target_path, "*.png"))
    
    print("[info] num expected labels: {}  num pre-encoded labels: {}".format(expected,len(pre_encoded)))

`

I added a pull request to the repo. For the time being, hope this helps!

I really appreciate this effort!

[hjhjb]

我已收到，谢谢

[CharisWg]

@farnaznouraei
after I used your code, I got the following errors: can you fix it?
Traceback (most recent call last):
File "/datashare3/charis/code/recaps/pytorch-semseg-master1/train.py", line 229, in
train(cfg, writer, logger)
File "/datashare3/charis/code/recaps/pytorch-semseg-master1/train.py", line 44, in train
t_loader = data_loader(
File "/datashare3/charis/anaconda/envs/recap/lib/python3.8/typing.py", line 875, in new
obj = super().new(cls, *args, **kwds)
TypeError: object.new() takes exactly one argument (the type to instantiate)

[hjhjb]

我已收到，谢谢

[CharisWg]

Dear hjhjb, 能臀医�Q@����}�幔 Charis xx

…

________________________________ From: hjhjb ***@***.***> Sent: Tuesday, 14 November 2023 9:34 AM To: meetps/pytorch-semseg ***@***.***> Cc: Wei-Chien Wang ***@***.***>; Comment ***@***.***> Subject: Re: [meetps/pytorch-semseg] Any good results from SegNet? (#246) 我已收到，谢谢 ― Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub<#246 (comment)>, or unsubscribe<https://github.com/notifications/unsubscribe-auth/AMHNU4V3DTUISGLNRKQ3OMTYEKOAJAVCNFSM4SKOSR42U5DIOJSWCZC7NNSXTN2JONZXKZKDN5WW2ZLOOQ5TCOBQHEZDIMZQGM2Q>. You are receiving this because you commented.Message ID: ***@***.***>

[CharisWg]

Dear hjhjb, �]事,我自己解�Q了,xx Chari

…

________________________________ From: Wei-Chien Wang ***@***.***> Sent: Tuesday, 14 November 2023 10:42 AM To: meetps/pytorch-semseg ***@***.***> Subject: Re: [meetps/pytorch-semseg] Any good results from SegNet? (#246) Dear hjhjb, 能臀医�Q@����}�幔 Charis xx

________________________________ From: hjhjb ***@***.***> Sent: Tuesday, 14 November 2023 9:34 AM To: meetps/pytorch-semseg ***@***.***> Cc: Wei-Chien Wang ***@***.***>; Comment ***@***.***> Subject: Re: [meetps/pytorch-semseg] Any good results from SegNet? (#246) 我已收到，谢谢 ― Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub<#246 (comment)>, or unsubscribe<https://github.com/notifications/unsubscribe-auth/AMHNU4V3DTUISGLNRKQ3OMTYEKOAJAVCNFSM4SKOSR42U5DIOJSWCZC7NNSXTN2JONZXKZKDN5WW2ZLOOQ5TCOBQHEZDIMZQGM2Q>. You are receiving this because you commented.Message ID: ***@***.***>

[CharisWg]

你好 我用了你的程式segNet,Y果全黑,我*255�是ㄧ � 能臀医�Q,有co急 Charis

…

________________________________ From: hjhjb ***@***.***> Sent: Tuesday, 14 November 2023 9:34 AM To: meetps/pytorch-semseg ***@***.***> Cc: Wei-Chien Wang ***@***.***>; Comment ***@***.***> Subject: Re: [meetps/pytorch-semseg] Any good results from SegNet? (#246) 我已收到，谢谢 ― Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub<#246 (comment)>, or unsubscribe<https://github.com/notifications/unsubscribe-auth/AMHNU4V3DTUISGLNRKQ3OMTYEKOAJAVCNFSM4SKOSR42U5DIOJSWCZC7NNSXTN2JONZXKZKDN5WW2ZLOOQ5TCOBQHEZDIMZQGM2Q>. You are receiving this because you commented.Message ID: ***@***.***>