-
Notifications
You must be signed in to change notification settings - Fork 1
/
04_trials_pilot.js
2122 lines (2106 loc) · 144 KB
/
04_trials_pilot.js
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
40
41
42
43
44
45
46
47
48
49
50
51
52
53
54
55
56
57
58
59
60
61
62
63
64
65
66
67
68
69
70
71
72
73
74
75
76
77
78
79
80
81
82
83
84
85
86
87
88
89
90
91
92
93
94
95
96
97
98
99
100
101
102
103
104
105
106
107
108
109
110
111
112
113
114
115
116
117
118
119
120
121
122
123
124
125
126
127
128
129
130
131
132
133
134
135
136
137
138
139
140
141
142
143
144
145
146
147
148
149
150
151
152
153
154
155
156
157
158
159
160
161
162
163
164
165
166
167
168
169
170
171
172
173
174
175
176
177
178
179
180
181
182
183
184
185
186
187
188
189
190
191
192
193
194
195
196
197
198
199
200
201
202
203
204
205
206
207
208
209
210
211
212
213
214
215
216
217
218
219
220
221
222
223
224
225
226
227
228
229
230
231
232
233
234
235
236
237
238
239
240
241
242
243
244
245
246
247
248
249
250
251
252
253
254
255
256
257
258
259
260
261
262
263
264
265
266
267
268
269
270
271
272
273
274
275
276
277
278
279
280
281
282
283
284
285
286
287
288
289
290
291
292
293
294
295
296
297
298
299
300
301
302
303
304
305
306
307
308
309
310
311
312
313
314
315
316
317
318
319
320
321
322
323
324
325
326
327
328
329
330
331
332
333
334
335
336
337
338
339
340
341
342
343
344
345
346
347
348
349
350
351
352
353
354
355
356
357
358
359
360
361
362
363
364
365
366
367
368
369
370
371
372
373
374
375
376
377
378
379
380
381
382
383
384
385
386
387
388
389
390
391
392
393
394
395
396
397
398
399
400
401
402
403
404
405
406
407
408
409
410
411
412
413
414
415
416
417
418
419
420
421
422
423
424
425
426
427
428
429
430
431
432
433
434
435
436
437
438
439
440
441
442
443
444
445
446
447
448
449
450
451
452
453
454
455
456
457
458
459
460
461
462
463
464
465
466
467
468
469
470
471
472
473
474
475
476
477
478
479
480
481
482
483
484
485
486
487
488
489
490
491
492
493
494
495
496
497
498
499
500
501
502
503
504
505
506
507
508
509
510
511
512
513
514
515
516
517
518
519
520
521
522
523
524
525
526
527
528
529
530
531
532
533
534
535
536
537
538
539
540
541
542
543
544
545
546
547
548
549
550
551
552
553
554
555
556
557
558
559
560
561
562
563
564
565
566
567
568
569
570
571
572
573
574
575
576
577
578
579
580
581
582
583
584
585
586
587
588
589
590
591
592
593
594
595
596
597
598
599
600
601
602
603
604
605
606
607
608
609
610
611
612
613
614
615
616
617
618
619
620
621
622
623
624
625
626
627
628
629
630
631
632
633
634
635
636
637
638
639
640
641
642
643
644
645
646
647
648
649
650
651
652
653
654
655
656
657
658
659
660
661
662
663
664
665
666
667
668
669
670
671
672
673
674
675
676
677
678
679
680
681
682
683
684
685
686
687
688
689
690
691
692
693
694
695
696
697
698
699
700
701
702
703
704
705
706
707
708
709
710
711
712
713
714
715
716
717
718
719
720
721
722
723
724
725
726
727
728
729
730
731
732
733
734
735
736
737
738
739
740
741
742
743
744
745
746
747
748
749
750
751
752
753
754
755
756
757
758
759
760
761
762
763
764
765
766
767
768
769
770
771
772
773
774
775
776
777
778
779
780
781
782
783
784
785
786
787
788
789
790
791
792
793
794
795
796
797
798
799
800
801
802
803
804
805
806
807
808
809
810
811
812
813
814
815
816
817
818
819
820
821
822
823
824
825
826
827
828
829
830
831
832
833
834
835
836
837
838
839
840
841
842
843
844
845
846
847
848
849
850
851
852
853
854
855
856
857
858
859
860
861
862
863
864
865
866
867
868
869
870
871
872
873
874
875
876
877
878
879
880
881
882
883
884
885
886
887
888
889
890
891
892
893
894
895
896
897
898
899
900
901
902
903
904
905
906
907
908
909
910
911
912
913
914
915
916
917
918
919
920
921
922
923
924
925
926
927
928
929
930
931
932
933
934
935
936
937
938
939
940
941
942
943
944
945
946
947
948
949
950
951
952
953
954
955
956
957
958
959
960
961
962
963
964
965
966
967
968
969
970
971
972
973
974
975
976
977
978
979
980
981
982
983
984
985
986
987
988
989
990
991
992
993
994
995
996
997
998
999
1000
// In this file you can specify the trial data for your experiment
// info important to create tirals
// vignettes is an object which contains all necessary information for the trials
let vignettes_or = {
lll: [{
"ID": 7,
"name": "Jimmy's trip",
"author": "micha",
"polina’s comments": "fine. For consistency, we might use “Jimmy’s brother” instead of brother in the inference questions",
"thoughts": "Bob: Is it unlikely to visit both the Statue of Liberty and the Empire State Building? -> Natalie: With only one hour for a city that large, I'd say yes.",
"final comments": "NA",
"final_selection": 1,
"type": "lll",
"relevance": 0,
"competence": 0,
"prior": 0,
"background": "Jimmy skipped school to go on a day-trip to New York City last week. Having to be back in the afternoon, he barely had one hour to spend in the city. Jimmy's younger brother, who is very talkative even if he doesn't know what he is talking about, told the neighbors about the trip afterwards.",
"utterance_or": "Jimmy's younger brother told the neighbors: 'Jimmy visited the Statue of Liberty or the Empire State Building.'",
"utterance_disj1": "Jimmy's younger brother told the neighbors: 'Jimmy visited the Statue of Liberty.'",
"utterance_disj2": "Jimmy's younger brother told the neighbors: 'Jimmy visited the Empire State Building.'",
"question_rel": "It is important for the neighbors to know whether Jimmy visited both the Statue of Liberty and the Empire State Building on his day-trip.",
"question_comp": "Jimmy's brother knows whether Jimmy visited both the Statue of Liberty and the Empire State Building on his day-trip.",
"question_pri1": "If Jimmy visited the Statue of Liberty, it is likely that he also visited the Empire State Building on his day-trip.",
"question_pri2": "If Jimmy visited the Empire State Building, it is likely that he also visited the Statue of Liberty on his day-trip.",
"question_pri_and": "It is likely that Jimmy visited both the Statue of Liberty and the Empire State Building on his day-trip. ",
"question_xor": "From what Jimmy's brother said we may conclude that Jimmy did not visit both the Statue of Liberty and the Empire State Building.",
"question_xorI": "Jimmy's brother wanted to convey that Jimmy did not visit both the Statue of Liberty and the Empire State Building.",
"question_exh1": "From what Jimmy's brother said we may conclude that Jimmy did not visit the Empire State Building as well.",
"question_exh2": "From what Jimmy's brother said we may conclude that Jimmy did not visit the Statue of Liberty as well.",
"test_true": "Jimmy had to rush to be back home and did not have much time to spend in the city.",
"test_false": "Jimmy went on a school trip to New York City.",
"test_uncertain": "Jimmy had told his friends about his plans to visit New York City before.",
"test_true1": "Jimmy has a sibling.",
"test_true2": "Jimmy goes to school.",
"test_false1": "Jimmy's brother went to New York City with Jimmy.",
"test_false2": "Jimmy is an exemplary student.",
"test_uncertain1": "Jimmy's parents know that he went to New York City.",
"test_uncertain2": "Jimmy's brother has been to New York City last year."
},
// {
// "ID": 15,
// "name": "Harold's pet",
// "author": "bob",
// "polina’s comments": "fine",
// "thoughts": "NA",
// "final comments": "NA",
// "final_selection": 1,
// "type": "lll",
// "relevance": 0,
// "competence": 0,
// "prior": 0,
// "background": "Richard and Tom are talking about Harold. Harold has been wanting a pet for a long time but his girlfriend wouldn't let him. Richard heard she finally gave in.",
// "utterance_or": "Richard says to Tom: 'Harold bought a cat or a dog.'",
// "utterance_disj1": "Richard says to Tom: 'Harold bought a cat.'",
// "utterance_disj2": "Richard says to Tom: 'Harold bought a dog.'",
// "question_rel": "It is important for Tom to know whether Harold bought both a cat and a dog.",
// "question_comp": "Richard knows whether Harold bought both a cat and a dog.",
// "question_pri1": "If Harold bought a cat, it is likely that he bought a dog as well.",
// "question_pri2": "If Harold bought a dog, it is likely that he bought a cat as well.",
// "question_pri_and": "It is likely that Harold bought both a cat and a dog.",
// "question_xor": "From what Richard said we may conclude that Harold did not buy both a cat and a dog.",
// "question_xorI": "Richard wants to convey that Harold did not buy both a cat and a dog.",
// "question_exh1": "From what Richard said we may conclude that Harold did not buy a dog as well.",
// "question_exh2": "From what Richard said we may conclude that Harold did not buy a cat as well.",
// "test_true": "Harold's girlfriend didn't want a pet in her house before.",
// "test_false": "Harold is single.",
// "test_uncertain": "Harold's girlfriend gave in because Harold kept nagging her about wanting a pet.",
// "test_true1": "Harold has a girlfriend.",
// "test_true2": "Richard and Tom are friends with Harold.",
// "test_false1": "Harold used to have a parrot.",
// "test_false2": "Tom and Harold are roommates.",
// "test_uncertain1": "Harold's girlfriend is afraid that pets will ruin the apartment.",
// "test_uncertain2": "Richard has a dog."
// },
// {
// "ID": 16,
// "name": "Dave's kids",
// "author": "natalie",
// "polina’s comments": "maybe add an indication of how old they are, like “On their fifth college graduation anniveersary, Kim and Jason are talking…” to make the low prior more salient",
// "thoughts": "Natalie: might be biased by time span since marriage (if they got married only recently, it's less likely that they already have several kids). Bob: the question might make the conjunction more relevant. Not sure about competence.",
// "final comments": "NA",
// "final_selection": 1,
// "type": "lll",
// "relevance": 0,
// "competence": 0,
// "prior": 0,
// "background": "Kim and Jason are talking about their old college friend Dave. Kim heard that he got married a few months ago and asks Jason whether Dave has any children.",
// "utterance_or": "Jason says to Kim: 'He has a son or a daughter.'",
// "utterance_disj1": "Jason says to Kim: 'He has a son.'",
// "utterance_disj2": "Jason says to Kim: 'He has a daughter.'",
// "question_rel": "It is important for Kim to know whether Dave has both a son and a daughter.",
// "question_comp": "Jason knows whether Dave has both a son and a daugther.",
// "question_pri1": "If Jason has a son, it is likely that he has a daugther as well.",
// "question_pri2": "If Jason has a daugther, it is likely that he has a son as well.",
// "question_pri_and": "It is likely that Dave has both a son and a daughter. ",
// "question_xor": "From what Jason said we may conclude that Dave does not have both a son and a daughter.",
// "question_xorI": "Jason wants to convey that Dave does not have both a son and a daughter.",
// "question_exh1": "From what Jason said we may conclude that Dave does not have a daughter as well.",
// "question_exh2": "From what Jason said we may conclude that Dave does not have a son as well.",
// "test_true": "Jason went to college with Dave.",
// "test_false": "Dave does not know Kim.",
// "test_uncertain": "Dave lives in Canada.",
// "test_true1": "Dave’s wedding was a few month ago.",
// "test_true2": "Kim has a higher education.",
// "test_false1": "Kim and Dave are siblings.",
// "test_false2": "Dave is divorced.",
// "test_uncertain1": "Kim and Jason have not seen Dave in five years.",
// "test_uncertain2": "Dave’s wife went to college with them, too."
// },
// {
// "ID": 41,
// "name": "Brad Pitt",
// "author": "bob",
// "polina’s comments": "I think this one is better than the original DiCaprio item, because it’s less confusing as to which actor is meant, and there is no “I think” in the utterance",
// "thoughts": "NA",
// "final comments": "NA",
// "final_selection": 1,
// "type": "lll",
// "relevance": 0,
// "competence": 0,
// "prior": 0,
// "background": "Sandra and Susie are watching a movie with Brad Pitt. Sandra vaguely remembers another movie with Brad Pitt and tells Susie about it.",
// "utterance_or": "Sandra says to Susie: ‘Brad Pitt played a fireman or a special agent in that other movie.'",
// "utterance_disj1": "Sandra says to Susie: ‘Brad Pitt played a fireman in that other movie.'",
// "utterance_disj2": "Sandra says to Susie: ‘Brad Pitt played special agent in that other movie.'",
// "question_rel": "It is important for Susie to know whether Brad Pitt played both a fireman and a special agent in that other movie.",
// "question_comp": "Sandra knows whether Brad Pitt played both a fireman and a special agent in that other movie.",
// "question_pri1": "If Brad Pitt played a fireman in that other movie, it is likely that he also played a special agent in that other movie.",
// "question_pri2": "If Brad Pitt a special agent in that other movie, it is likely that he also played a fireman in that other movie.",
// "question_pri_and": "It is likely that Brad Pitt played both a fireman and a special agent in that other movie.",
// "question_xor": "From what Sandra said we may conclude that Brad Pitt did not play both a fireman and a special agent in that other movie.",
// "question_xorI": "Sandra wants to convey that Brad Pitt did not play both a fireman and a special agent in that other movie.",
// "question_exh1": "From what Sandra said we may conclude that Brad Pitt was not a fireman in that other movie as well.",
// "question_exh2": "From what Sandra said we may conclude that Brad Pitt was not a special agent in that other movie as well.",
// "test_true": "Sandra and Susie have a movie night.",
// "test_false": "Sandra is talking about another movie with Leonardo DiCaprio.",
// "test_uncertain": "Sandra and Susie have a movie night every weekend.",
// "test_true1": "Brad Pitt is an actor.",
// "test_true2": "Sandra and Susie like Brad Pitt.",
// "test_false1": "Brad Pitt is playing the bad guy in that other movie.",
// "test_false2": "Sandra doesn't remember Brad Pitt at all.",
// "test_uncertain1": "Sandra likes Sandra Bullock.",
// "test_uncertain2": "Susie has watched many movies with Will Smith."
// }
],
llh: [ {
"ID": 6,
"name": "Joshua's delay",
"author": "micha",
"polina’s comments": "not sure if relevance is really low here if Kevin thinks that Joshua doesn’t like to play with them anymore – if he had to do both that might mean that it’s not the case that Joshua doesn’t like to play with them anymore (so we could remove the chunk about Kevin’s thougths?..)",
"thoughts": "Bob: Is it likely to both have lunch and do homework? -> Micha: added information that the parents are strict, hope that pushes the likelihood, but yes, not very strong item. Bob: Maybe add 'both' to question_rel and question_comp -> Natalie: The way it is worded now, I find it quite likely that both is true.",
"final comments": "check if the comp / rel / pri questions make sense",
"final_selection": 1,
"type": "llh",
"relevance": 0,
"competence": 0,
"prior": 1,
"background": "Kevin, Cory and Joshua are 7-year-olds from the same neighborhood. They are friends but argue a lot. Yesterday Joshua, who has very strict parents who usually make him do chores before he can go out, was later than usual to arrive at their hang-out. Kevin thinks that Joshua doesn’t like to play with them anymore.",
"utterance_or": "Cory says to Kevin: 'Joshua had to clean his room or do his homework.'",
"utterance_disj1": "Cory says to Kevin: 'Joshua had to clean his room.'",
"utterance_disj2": "Cory says to Kevin: 'Joshua had to do his homework.'",
"question_rel": "It is important for Kevin to know whether Joshua had to both clean his room and do his homework before coming to the hang-out.",
"question_comp": "Cory knows whether Joshua had to both clean his room and do his homework before coming to the hang-out.",
"question_pri1": "If Joshua had to do his homework, it is likely that he also had to clean his room before coming to the hang-out.",
"question_pri2": "If Joshua had to clean is room, it is likely that he also had to do his homework before coming to the hang-out.",
"question_pri_and": "It is likely that Joshua had to both clean his room and do his homework before coming to the hang-out.",
"question_xor": "From what Cory said we may conclude that Joshua did not have to both clean his room and do his homework.",
"question_xorI": "Cory wanted to convey that Joshua did not have to both clean his room and do his homework.",
"question_exh1": "From what Cory said we may conclude that Joshua did not have to do his homework as well.",
"question_exh2": "From what Cory said we may conclude that Joshua did not have to clean his room as well.",
"test_true": "Kevin and Cory expected Joshua to arrive earlier.",
"test_false": "Kevin, Cory and Joshua are brothers.",
"test_uncertain": "Kevin, Cory and Joshua do not like to hang out with girls.",
"test_true1": "Cory is in elementary school.",
"test_true2": "Joshua's parents don't allow him to play before doing his chores.",
"test_false1": "Kevin cannot stand Joshua.",
"test_false2": "Kevin and Cory are teenagers.",
"test_uncertain1": "Kevin already finished his homework for today.",
"test_uncertain2": "The boys like to play hide and seek."
},
// {
// "ID": 14,
// "name": "Gerald's graduation",
// "author": "bob",
// "polina’s comments": "fine",
// "thoughts": "NA",
// "final comments": "NA",
// "final_selection": 1,
// "type": "llh",
// "relevance": 0,
// "competence": 0,
// "prior": 1,
// "background": "Nico and Rick are talking about their mutual friend Gerald. Gerald has been studying for ages. Gerald’s parents have always been very supportive to this very day and they are a close, traditional family. Nico heard he recently graduated and tells Rick about the ceremony.",
// "utterance_or": "Nico says to Rick: 'His mother or his father attended the ceremony.'",
// "utterance_disj1": "Nico says to Rick: 'His mother attended the ceremony.'",
// "utterance_disj2": "Nico says to Rick: 'His father attended the ceremony.'",
// "question_rel": "It is important for Rick to know whether both Gerald's mother and his father attended the ceremony.",
// "question_comp": "Nico knows whether both Gerald's mother and his father attended the ceremony.",
// "question_pri1": "If Gerald's mother attended the ceremony, it is likely that his father attended as well.",
// "question_pri2": "If Gerald's father attended the ceremony, it is likely that his mother attended as well.",
// "question_pri_and": "It is likely that both Gerald’s mother and his father attended the ceremony.",
// "question_xor": "From what Nico said we may conclude that Gerald's mother and his father did not both attend the ceremony.",
// "question_xorI": "Nico wants to convey that Gerald's mother and his father did not both attend the ceremony.",
// "question_exh1": "From what Nico said we may conclude that Gerald's father did not attend the ceremony as well.",
// "question_exh2": "From what Nico said we may conclude that Gerald's mother did not attend the ceremony as well.",
// "test_true": "Gerald is friends with both Nico and Rick.",
// "test_false": "Nico finally graduated after studying for a long time.",
// "test_uncertain": "Gerald took almost ten years to graduate.",
// "test_true1": "Gerald has a higher education. ",
// "test_true2": "Nico did not attend Gerald’s graduation ceremony.",
// "test_false1": "Eric is Gerald’s professor.",
// "test_false2": "Gerald just graduated from high school.",
// "test_uncertain1": "Gerald, Nico and Rick went to school together.",
// "test_uncertain2": "Gerald studied Computer Science."
// },
// {
// "ID": 22,
// "name": "Greg's movie",
// "author": "natalie",
// "polina’s comments": "not really sure about the prior or relevance here. Maybe make the context about a new movie that was released recently and that everyone wants to see? That would also make the first sentence sound more natural if it was “Greg wants to see the new movie…”. Agree with the comment about comptenece. Same issue with prior questions. ",
// "thoughts": "Natalie: competence difficult to assess because of future intention; 'A movie' might be ambiguous between de dicto/de re reading, but 'THAT movie' should resolve it (not directly relevant to the XOR anway). Bob: not sure about prior",
// "final comments": "not sure about competence because of future intentions; updated relevance to 0; check pilot ratings on competence (updated to 0)",
// "final_selection": 1,
// "type": "llh",
// "relevance": 0,
// "competence": 0,
// "prior": 1,
// "background": "Greg wants to see the new Star Wars movie that everyone has been talking about and thinks about joining Kira, who planned to watch that movie in the cinema that night. He asks her who else is coming.",
// "utterance_or": "Kira says to Greg: 'I am going with Mohammed or Stephanie.'",
// "utterance_disj1": "Kira says to Greg: 'I am going with Mohammed.'",
// "utterance_disj2": "Kira says to Greg: 'I am going with Stephanie.'",
// "question_rel": "It is important for Greg to know whether Kira is going with both Mohammed and Stephanie.",
// "question_comp": "Kira knows whether she is going with both Mohammed and Stephanie.",
// "question_pri1": "If Kira is going with Mohammed, it is likely that she is going with Stephanie as well.",
// "question_pri2": "If Kira is going with Stephanie, it is likely that she is going with Mohammed as well.",
// "question_pri_and": "It is likely that Kira is hoing with both Mohammed and Stephanie. ",
// "question_xor": "From what Kira said we may conclude that she is not going with both Mohammed and Stephanie.",
// "question_xorI": "Kira wants to convey that she is not going with both Mohammed and Stephanie.",
// "question_exh1": "From what Kira said we may conclude that she is not going with Stephanie as well.",
// "question_exh2": "From what Kira said we may conclude that she is not going with Mohammed as well.",
// "test_true": "Greg considers going to the cinema tonight.",
// "test_false": "Greg would rather watch a different movie than the one Kira is going to watch.",
// "test_uncertain": "Greg does not like Kira’s friends.",
// "test_true1": "Greg likes movies.",
// "test_true2": "Kira plans to meet friends tonight.",
// "test_false1": "Greg hates Star Wars.",
// "test_false2": "Kira does not like going out.",
// "test_uncertain1": "Greg and Kira already went to the cinema together last week.",
// "test_uncertain2": "Greg considers going to the cinema with his sister tomorrow instead."
// },
// {
// "ID": 25,
// "name": "Alissa's paint",
// "author": "natalie",
// "polina’s comments": "not sure about the prior either. ",
// "thoughts": "Bob: not sure about prior.",
// "final comments": "NA",
// "final_selection": 1,
// "type": "llh",
// "relevance": 0,
// "competence": 0,
// "prior": 1,
// "background": "Fiona just got off a video call with her daughter Alissa who recently re-painted the walls in her apartment. Alissa had to re-paint her apartment with a tight budget. Fiona tells her brother Butch about it.",
// "utterance_or": "Fiona says to Butch: 'She used off-white for the bedroom or the guest room.'",
// "utterance_disj1": "Fiona says to Butch: 'She used off-white for the bedroom.'",
// "utterance_disj2": "Fiona says to Butch: 'She used off-white for the guest room.'",
// "question_rel": "It is important for Butch to know whether Alissa used off-white for both the bedroom and the guest room.",
// "question_comp": "Fiona knows whether Alissa used off-white for both the bedroom and the guest room.",
// "question_pri1": "If Alissa used off-white for the bedroom, it is likely that she used off-white for the guest room as well.",
// "question_pri2": "If Alissa used off-white for the guest room, it is likely that she used off-white for the bedroom as well.",
// "question_pri_and": "It is likely that Alissa used off-white for both the bedroom and the guest room. ",
// "question_xor": "From what Fiona said we may conclude that Alissa did not use off-white for both the bedroom and the guest room.",
// "question_xorI": "Fiona wants to convey that Alissa did not use off-white for both the bedroom and the guest room.",
// "question_exh1": "From what Fiona said we may conclude that Alissa did not use off-white for the guest room as well.",
// "question_exh2": "From what Fiona said we may conclude that Alissa did not use off-white for the bedroom as well.",
// "test_true": "Alissa has an apartment.",
// "test_false": "Fiona is Alissa's sister.",
// "test_uncertain": "Alissa painted the living room pale blue.",
// "test_true1": "Butch is Alissa’s uncle.",
// "test_true2": "Alissa recently bought paint for her apartment. ",
// "test_false1": "Fiona hasn’t visited Alissa since her renovation.",
// "test_false2": "Butch is Alissa’s father.",
// "test_uncertain1": "Fiona wants to re-paint her apartment now, too.",
// "test_uncertain2": "Alissa also got new furniture."
// }
],
lhl: [ {
"ID": 5,
"name": "Tony's clubbing",
"author": "micha",
"polina’s comments": "to me, the word “occasionally” makes it sound like Rob actually might not have that high competence about the kind of music there is going to be that night since he might not work there on that day?",
"thoughts": "Bob: Not sure whether 'test_false' is really false or rather uncertain. -> Natalie: In my intuition, not using a modifier like 'also'/'too' when mentioning that Rob works there has a rather strong implicature that Tony doesn't. But this isn't a logical necessity, so a test that is more clearly false (e.g. 'Tony much prefers rock music over Techno') might be useful",
"final comments": "NA",
"final_selection": 1,
"type": "lhl",
"relevance": 0,
"competence": 1,
"prior": 0,
"background": "Tony loves to dance to electronic music, preferably Techno. The simpler and more monotonic, the better. He contemplates going to club Macabre tonight, but he has no idea what music they play. He phones his friend Rob who works at club Macabre as a bartender.",
"utterance_or": "Rob tells Tony: 'They play Jazz or Metal tonight.'",
"utterance_disj1": "Rob tells Tony: 'They play Jazz tonight.'",
"utterance_disj2": "Rob tells Tony: 'They play Metal tonight.'",
"question_rel": "It is important for Tony to know whether they play both Jazz and Metal at the club tonight.",
"question_comp": "Rob knows whether they play both Jazz and Metal at the club tonight.",
"question_pri1": "If they play Jazz at the club tonight, it is likely that they also play Metal.",
"question_pri2": "If they play Metal at the club tonight, it is likely that they also play Jazz.",
"question_pri_and": "It is likely that they play both Jazz and Metal at the club tonight.",
"question_xor": "From what Rob said we may conclude that they do not play both Jazz and Metal tonight.",
"question_xorI": "Rob wanted to convey that they do not play both Jazz and Metal tonight.",
"question_exh1": "From what Rob said we may conclude that they do not play Metal as well tonight.",
"question_exh2": "From what Rob said we may conclude that they do not play Jazz as well tonight.",
"test_true": "Techno is quite different from Jazz and from Metal.",
"test_false": "Tony prefers Rock over Techno music.",
"test_uncertain": "Rob is a big fan of Techno music as well.",
"test_true1": "Tony likes to go out.",
"test_true2": "Rob knows how to make drinks.",
"test_false1": "Tony considers going to an anthropology lecture tonight.",
"test_false2": "Rob works as a DJ at club Macabre.",
"test_uncertain1": "Tony composes Techno music himself.",
"test_uncertain2": "Rob's favorite music is Jazz."
},
// {
// "ID": 13,
// "name": "Lily's husband",
// "author": "bob",
// "polina’s comments": "I feel like relevance might actually be high here. Not sure if I’m thinking too far off, but if the husband is an alcoholic the prior might also be high, and then the drinking buddy might also be unreliable (for him to sound more reliable, maybe we could write “his friend Bill Eric went out with last night”?)",
// "thoughts": "NA",
// "final comments": "not sure about prior (in case he was an alcoholic?)",
// "final_selection": 1,
// "type": "lhl",
// "relevance": 0,
// "competence": 1,
// "prior": 0,
// "background": "Lily is worried that her husband Eric is still drinking despite the doctor's orders not to drink any alcohol at all. She phones up Eric's buddy Bill who went to a bar with him last night. Bill tells her about their night.",
// "utterance_or": "Bill tells Lily: 'Your husband drank whisky or vodka.'",
// "utterance_disj1": "Bill tells Lily: 'Your husband drank whisky.'",
// "utterance_disj2": "Bill tells Lily: 'Your husband drank vodka.'",
// "question_rel": "It is important for Lily to know whether her husband drank both whisky and vodka last night.",
// "question_comp": "Bill knows whether Eric drank both whisky and vodka last night.",
// "question_pri1": "If Eric drank whisky, it is likely that he drank vodka last night as well.",
// "question_pri2": "If Eric drank vodka, it is likely that he drank whisky last night as well.",
// "question_pri_and": "It is likely that Eric drank both whisky and vodka last night. ",
// "question_xor": "From what Bill said we may conclude that Eric did not drink both whisky and vodka.",
// "question_xorI": "Bill wants to convey that Eric did not drink both whisky and vodka.",
// "question_exh1": "From what Bill said we may conclude that Eric did not drink vodka as well.",
// "question_exh2": "From what Bill said we may conclude that Eric did not drink whisky as well.",
// "test_true": "Eric's doctor told him to stop drinking alcohol.",
// "test_false": "Eric and Lily went to a bar together last night.",
// "test_uncertain": "Eric has a problem with his liver for which he has to stop drinking alcohol.",
// "test_true1": "Eric and Bill went our last night.",
// "test_true2": "Lily is married.",
// "test_false1": "Bill had dinner and stayed at home last night.",
// "test_false2": "Eric and Bill went to see a football game last night.",
// "test_uncertain1": "Eric’s doctor told him to stop eating fast food, as well. ",
// "test_uncertain2": "Lily does not drink alcohol."
// },
// {
// "ID": 39,
// "name": "Rumors",
// "author": "neele",
// "polina’s comments": "agreed with MF",
// "thoughts": "MF: prior low?, comp high? Bob: I agree about Competence. Prior might indeed be problematic because it sounds like John and his wife haven't had time to watch TV or listen to the radio. True1 isn't true because it's just a rumour right?",
// "final comments": "updated comp and pri",
// "final_selection": 1,
// "type": "lhl",
// "relevance": 0,
// "competence": 1,
// "prior": 0,
// "background": "John and his wife are eating dinner. They have been extremely busy all day in connection with their stressful jobs as real estate agents. But now, in the evening, they finally have time to sit down and talk to each other. They are discussing a rumor saying that a famous singer has committed suicide in the morning.",
// "utterance_or": "His wife says to John: 'I heard about the rumor on TV or on the radio.'",
// "utterance_disj1": "His wife says to John: 'I heard about the rumor on TV.'",
// "utterance_disj2": "His wife says to John: 'I heard about the rumor on the radio.'",
// "question_rel": "It is important for John to know whether his wife heard about the rumor both on TV and on the radio.",
// "question_comp": "John's wife knows whether she heard about the rumor both on TV and on the radio.",
// "question_pri1": "If John's wife heard about the rumor on TV, it is likely that she also heard about the rumor on the radio.",
// "question_pri2": "If John's wife heard about the rumor on the radio, it is likely that she also heard about the rumor on TV.",
// "question_pri_and": "It is likely that John’s wife heard about the rumor both on TV and on the radio.",
// "question_xor": "From what John's wife said we may conclude that she did not hear about the rumor both on TV and on the radio.",
// "question_xorI": "John's wife wants to convey that she did not hear about the rumor both on TV and on the radio.",
// "question_exh1": "From what John's wife said we may conclude that she did not hear about the rumor on the radio as well.",
// "question_exh2": "From what John's wife said we may conclude that she did not hear about the rumor on TV as well.",
// "test_true": "John and his wife both work in real estate.",
// "test_false": "John works as a car mechanic.",
// "test_uncertain": "John’s wife’s name is Martha.",
// "test_true1": "A famous singer might have died.",
// "test_true2": "John is married.",
// "test_false1": "John and his wife are eating breakfast.",
// "test_false2": "John's wife is on holiday.",
// "test_uncertain1": "John and his wife have a child.",
// "test_uncertain2": "John's last name is Miller."
// },
// {
// "ID": 40,
// "name": "Hippies",
// "author": "bob",
// "polina’s comments": "I like this one more than the previous hippies item (see my comment). Adjust the questions respectively",
// "thoughts": "Bob: This is one of the few (the only?) items where 'or' conjoins whole sentences. Maybe have something like a 'broken headlight or tail light' instead?",
// "final comments": "NA",
// "final_selection": 1,
// "type": "lhl",
// "relevance": 0,
// "competence": 1,
// "prior": 0,
// "background": "While driving home for Christmas, Paul stops his car at a gas station. He sees a policeman talking to a young couple in a colorful van. After the van pulls off, Paul starts chatting to the policeman about the couple.",
// "utterance_or": "The policeman says 'The van had a broken headlight or tail light.'",
// "utterance_disj1": "The policeman says: 'The headlight was broken.'",
// "utterance_disj2": "The policeman says: 'The tail light was broken.’",
// "question_rel": "It is important for Paul to know whether both the van's headlight and tail light was broken.",
// "question_comp": "The policeman knows whether both the van's headlight and tail light was broken.",
// "question_pri1": "If the van's headlight was broken, it is likely that the van’s tail light was broken as well.",
// "question_pri2": "If the van’s tail light was broken, it is likely that the van's headlight was broken as well.",
// "question_pri_and": "It is likely that both the van’s headlight and tail light was broken.",
// "question_xor": "From what the policeman said we may conclude that it it is not the case that both the van's headlight and tail light was broken.",
// "question_xorI": "The policeman wants to convey that that it it is not the case that both the van's headlight and tail light was broken.",
// "question_exh1": "From what the policeman said we may conclude that the van’s headlight was not broken as well.",
// "question_exh2": "From what the policeman said we may conclude that the van’s tail light was not broken as well.",
// "test_true": "Paul drives a motorized vehicle.",
// "test_false": "Paul took the train home.",
// "test_uncertain": "The policeman is on his way home, too.",
// "test_true1": "It's Christmas time.",
// "test_true2": "Paul is driving home.",
// "test_false1": "The policeman arrested Paul for murder.",
// "test_false2": "The couple's van is registered as a stolen vehicle.",
// "test_uncertain1": "Paul is having a coffee at the gas station.",
// "test_uncertain2": "Paul has a green car."
// }
],
lhh: [{
"ID": 4,
"name": "Bill's order",
"author": "micha",
"polina’s comments": "fine",
"thoughts": "NA",
"final comments": "NA",
"final_selection": 1,
"type": "lhh",
"relevance": 0,
"competence": 1,
"prior": 1,
"background": "Jake and Bill went jogging together in the afternoon. Afterwards they were very hungry and went to a restaurant. Later Jake ran into Bill's wife and told her about their lunch.",
"utterance_or": "Jake told Bill's wife: 'Bill ordered a starter or a side dish with his main course.'",
"utterance_disj1": "Jake told Bill's wife: 'Bill ordered a starter with his main course.'",
"utterance_disj2": "Jake told Bill's wife: 'Bill ordered a side dish with his main course.'",
"question_rel": "It is important for Bill's wife to know whether Bill ordered both a starter and a side dish with his main course.",
"question_comp": "Jake knows whether Bill ordered both a starter and a side dish with his main course.",
"question_pri1": "If Bill ordered a starter, it is likely that he also ordered a side dish with his main course.",
"question_pri2": "If Bill ordered a side dish, it is likely that he also ordered a starter with his main course.",
"question_pri_and": "It is likely that Bill ordered both a side dish and a starter with his main course. ",
"question_xor": "From what Jake said we may conclude that Bill did not order both a starter and a side dish.",
"question_xorI": "Jake wanted to convey that Bill did not order both a starter and a side dish.",
"question_exh1": "From what Jake said we may conclude that Bill did not order a side dish as well.",
"question_exh2": "From what Jake said we may conclude that Bill did not order a starter as well.",
"test_true": "Jake and Bill spent a lot of time together that day.",
"test_false": "Jake and Bill went to the restaurant before they went jogging.",
"test_uncertain": "Jake ordered a steak.",
"test_true1": "Bill and Jake like doing sports.",
"test_true2": "Bill is married.",
"test_false1": "Jake went home right after finishing the run.",
"test_false2": "Bill has a knee injury.",
"test_uncertain1": "Bill is a vegetarian.",
"test_uncertain2": "Jake is married."
},
// {
// "ID": 12,
// "name": "Chloe's holiday",
// "author": "bob",
// "polina’s comments": "fine, although the prior is not super salient",
// "thoughts": "Micha added the friend's names to the background story, because otherwise the prior questions are weird, when presented without the utterance. -- Susan bringing lotion and Amelia doing so are likely independent events; that makes the prior question a bit odd. Maybe phrase it unconditionally in case of purported independence. Natalie: background: reword 'forgot' to 'had forgotten'?",
// "final comments": "Susan bringing lotion and Amelia doing so are likely independent events; that makes the prior question a bit odd. Maybe phrase it unconditionally in case of purported independence",
// "final_selection": 1,
// "type": "lhh",
// "relevance": 0,
// "competence": 1,
// "prior": 1,
// "background": "Chloe is telling her father about her holidays with her two friends Susan and Amelia. Chloe had forgotten to bring suntan lotion.",
// "utterance_or": "Chloe tells her father: 'Susan or Amelia brought some extra suntan lotion I could use.'",
// "utterance_disj1": "Chloe tells her father: 'Susan brought some extra suntan lotion I could use.'",
// "utterance_disj2": "Chloe tells her father: 'Amelia brought some extra suntan lotion I could use.'",
// "question_rel": "It is important for Chloe's father to know whether both Susan and Amelia brought some extra suntan lotion that Chloe could use.",
// "question_comp": "Chloe knows whether both Susan and Amelia brought some extra suntan lotion that she could use.",
// "question_pri1": "If Susan brought some extra suntan lotion that Chloe could use, it is likely that Amelia brought some as well.",
// "question_pri2": "If Amelia brought some extra suntan lotion that Chloe could use, it is likely that Susan brought some as well.",
// "question_pri_and": "It is likely that both Susan and Amelia brought some extra suntan lotion that Chloe could use. ",
// "question_xor": "From what Chloe said we may conclude that Susan and Amelia did not both bring some extra suntan lotion.",
// "question_xorI": "Chloe wants to convey that Susan and Amelia did not both bring some extra suntan lotion.",
// "question_exh1": "From what Chloe said we may conclude that Amelia did not bring some extra suntan lotion as well.",
// "question_exh2": "From what Chloe said we may conclude that Susan did not bring some extra suntan lotion as well.",
// "test_true": "Chloe recently got back from holidays.",
// "test_false": "Chloe went on holidays with a big group of her friends.",
// "test_uncertain": "Chloe forgot about bringing some beach towels, too.",
// "test_true1": "Susan did not forget to bring protection against sunburns for the holiday.",
// "test_true2": "Chloe’s father did not go on holiday with his daughter.",
// "test_false1": "Amelia is Chloe’s sister. ",
// "test_false2": "The girls went to the rainy UK for their holiday.",
// "test_uncertain1": "Chloe spent ten days on holiday.",
// "test_uncertain2": "Amelia and Susan have never been on holiday before."
// },
// {
// "ID": 31,
// "name": "School",
// "author": "elisa",
// "polina’s comments": "I would write “does not excel” in the inference question for consistency, otherwise it’s fine",
// "thoughts": "NA",
// "final comments": "NA",
// "final_selection": 1,
// "type": "lhh",
// "relevance": 0,
// "competence": 1,
// "prior": 1,
// "background": "Julia's mum and Anna's mum wait for their children in front of the school. Julia's mum says that girls should be good at arts and languages. According to her, all other subjects are male domains.",
// "utterance_or": "Anna's mum says to Julia's mum: 'Anna excels at Math or Physics.'",
// "utterance_disj1": "Anna's mum says to Julia's mum: 'Anna excels at Math.'",
// "utterance_disj2": "Anna's mum says to Julia's mum: 'Anna excels at Physics.'",
// "question_rel": "It is important for Julia's mum to know whether Anna excels at both Math and Physics.",
// "question_comp": "Anna's mum knows whether Anna excels at both Math and Physics.",
// "question_pri1": "If Anna excels at Math, it is likely that she also excels at Physics.",
// "question_pri2": "If Anna excels at Physics, it is likely that she also excels at Math.",
// "question_pri_and": "It is likely that Anna excels at both Math and Physics.",
// "question_xor": "From what Anna's mum said we may conclude that Anna does not excel in both Math and Physics.",
// "question_xorI": "Anna's mum wants to convey that Anna does not excel at both Math and Physics.",
// "question_exh1": "From what Anna's mum said we may conclude that Anna does not excel in Physics as well.",
// "question_exh2": "From what Anna's mum said we may conclude that Anna does not excel in Math as well.",
// "test_true": "Anna and Julia are in the same school.",
// "test_false": "Julia's mum believes that girls should be good at Chemistry.",
// "test_uncertain": "After school, Anna and her mum plan to have ice cream.",
// "test_true1": "Anna is good at science subjects.",
// "test_true2": "Anna and Julia are about to finish school for the day.",
// "test_false1": "Anna is only good at French.",
// "test_false2": "Julia gets home by taking the bus by herself after school. ",
// "test_uncertain1": "Anna and Julia have been friends since first grade.",
// "test_uncertain2": "Anna’s and Julia’s families are neighbors, too."
// },
// {
// "ID": 38,
// "name": "Grandma",
// "author": "neele",
// "polina’s comments": "isn’t “coffee and cake” kind of conventionalized? (or is it German intuition coming through?;-)) also the wording that Gretchen is “visiting” her mother suggests that the mother is e.g. at home, making the following part of the utterance a little weird to me. Maybe “meets”?",
// "thoughts": "Bob: We should probably add 'at Cafe Toscana' to the Prior questions.",
// "final comments": "coffee and cake might be kind of conventionalized?",
// "final_selection": 1,
// "type": "lhh",
// "relevance": 0,
// "competence": 1,
// "prior": 1,
// "background": "Gretchen is meeting her mother Elsa, who had just previously met her own mother, Gretchen's grandmother, at Cafe Toscana in the city center. Elsa tells Gretchen about it.",
// "utterance_or": "Elsa tells Gretchen: 'I just had coffee or cake with your grandma at Cafe Toscana.'",
// "utterance_disj1": "Elsa tells Gretchen: 'I just had coffee with your grandma at Cafe Toscana.'",
// "utterance_disj2": "Elsa tells Gretchen: 'I just had cake with your grandma at Cafe Toscana.'",
// "question_rel": "It is important for Gretchen to know whether Elsa had both coffee and cake with her grandmother at Cafe Toscana.",
// "question_comp": "Elsa knows whether she had both coffee and cake with her mother at Cafe Toscana.",
// "question_pri1": "If Elsa had coffee, it is likely that she also had cake at Cafe Toscana.",
// "question_pri2": "If Elsa had cake, it is likely that she also had coffee at Cafe Toscana.",
// "question_pri_and": "It is likely that Elsa had both coffee and cake at Cafe Toscana.",
// "question_xor": "From what Elsa said we may conclude that she did not have both coffee and cake at Cafe Toscana.",
// "question_xorI": "Elsa wants to convey that she did not have both coffee and cake at Cafe Toscana.",
// "question_exh1": "From what Elsa said we may conclude that she did not have coffee at Cafe Toscana as well.",
// "question_exh2": "From what Elsa said we may conclude that she did not have cake at Cafe Toscana as well.",
// "test_true": "Gretchen’s grandmother is Elsa’s mother.",
// "test_false": "Gretchen is meeting her father.",
// "test_uncertain": "Elsa plans to go to the hairdresser tomorrow.",
// "test_true1": "Elsa is Gretchen's mother.",
// "test_true2": "There's a cafe named Cafe Toscana.",
// "test_false1": "Gretchen is Elsa's grandmother.",
// "test_false2": "Gretchen joined her mother and grandmother at Cafe Toscana.",
// "test_uncertain1": "Gretchen's brother has been at Cafe Toscana too.",
// "test_uncertain2": "Gretchen has blond hair."
// }
],
hll: [{
"ID": 3,
"name": "Carl's party",
"author": "micha",
"polina’s comments": "To make the competence condition more clear, I’d maybe make the sentence “For most of the evening, John helped out in the kitchen…”. Otherwise, the item is okay, but the whole situation seems to be a bit weird to me. Like if the ex-wives were invited in the first place, Carl might as well dance with them… And there might be politeness effects coming into play in John’s utterance. ",
"thoughts": "Bob: Is the conjunction relevant? -> Micha: my intuition is that Carl's wife would care to know, even if dancing with only one is already bad. -> Natalie: Same in my intuition.",
"final comments": "potential politeness effects",
"final_selection": 1,
"type": "hll",
"relevance": 1,
"competence": 0,
"prior": 0,
"background": "Many people came to Carl's garden party yesterday, including his ex-wives Sue and Mary. It was terribly crowded everywhere. For most of the evening, John helped out Carl's wife in the kitchen where it was much more quiet during most of the party. ",
"utterance_or": "Afterwards John told Carl's wife: 'Carl danced passionately with Sue or Mary.'",
"utterance_disj1": "Afterwards John told Carl's wife: 'Carl danced passionately with Sue.'",
"utterance_disj2": "Afterwards John told Carl's wife: 'Carl danced passionately with Mary.'",
"question_rel": "It is important for Carl's wife to know whether Carl danced passionately with both Sue and Mary.",
"question_comp": "John knows whether Carl danced passionately with both Sue and Mary.",
"question_pri1": "If Carl danced passionately with Sue, it is likely that he also danced passionately with Mary.",
"question_pri2": "If Carl danced passionately with Mary, it is likely that he also danced passionately with Sue.",
"question_pri_and": "It is likely that Carl danced passionately with both Sue and Mary.",
"question_xor": "From what John said we may conclude that Carl did not dance passionately with both Sue and Mary.",
"question_xorI": "John wanted to convey that Carl did not dance passionately with both Sue and Mary.",
"question_exh1": "From what John said we may conclude that Carl did not dance passionately with Mary as well.",
"question_exh2": "From what John said we may conclude that Carl did not dance passionately with Sue as well.",
"test_true": "John did not spend much time outside.",
"test_false": "John and Carl, the hosts, are a gay couple.",
"test_uncertain": "Carl's wife liked the music very much.",
"test_true1": "Carl is married.",
"test_true2": "Carl was married more than once.",
"test_false1": "John is Sue's husband.",
"test_false2": "Carl invited his guests to a restaurant.",
"test_uncertain1": "Carl's wife likes to dance tango.",
"test_uncertain2": "John secretly has a crush on Carl's wife."
},
// {
// "ID": 11,
// "name": "Leo's prize",
// "author": "bob",
// "polina’s comments": "fine. Maybe for a more clear competence, add “Hans who arrived just shortly before Leo tells…”?",
// "thoughts": "NA",
// "final comments": "NA",
// "final_selection": 1,
// "type": "hll",
// "relevance": 1,
// "competence": 0,
// "prior": 0,
// "background": "Leo is sponsoring a golf tournament. In particular, he provides a luxurious car for any hole-in-one. When Leo arrives at the tournament, his friend Hans who arrived shortly before him comes up to him to tell about the events so far.",
// "utterance_or": "Hans tells Leo: 'I heard someone just hit a hole-in-one on the first or second hole.'",
// "utterance_disj1": "Hans tells Leo: 'I heard someone just hit a hole-in-one on the first hole'",
// "utterance_disj2": "Hans tells Leo: 'I heard someone just hit a hole-in-one on the second hole.''",
// "question_rel": "It is important for Leo to know whether someone made a hole-in-one on both the first and the second hole.",
// "question_comp": "Hans knows whether someone just made a hole-in-one on both the first and the second hole.",
// "question_pri1": "If someone made a hole-in-one on the first hole, it is likely that she also made one on the second hole.",
// "question_pri2": "If someone made a hole-in-one on the second hole, it is likely that she also made one on the first hole.",
// "question_pri_and": "It is likely that someone made a hole-in-one on both the first and the second hole.",
// "question_xor": "From what Hans said we may conclude that the player in question didn't make a hole-in-one on both the first and the second hole.",
// "question_xorI": "Hans wants to convey that the player in question didn't make a hole-in-one on both the first and the second hole.",
// "question_exh1": "From what Hans said we may conclude that the player in question didn't make a hole-in-one on the second hole as well.",
// "question_exh2": "From what Hans said we may conclude that the player in question didn't make a hole-in-one on the first hole as well",
// "test_true": "Leo is wealthy.",
// "test_false": "Leo is sponsoring a tennis tournament.",
// "test_uncertain": "Leo is an avid golf player.",
// "test_true1": "Leo missed the beginning of the tournament.",
// "test_true2": "The players have a chance to win a luxurious vehicle. ",
// "test_false1": "Leo will provide a luxurious car for the winner of the tournament.",
// "test_false2": "Hans hit a hole-in-one.",
// "test_uncertain1": "Hans is sponsoring the tournament, too.",
// "test_uncertain2": "Hans’s wife participates in the tournament."
// },
// {
// "ID": 32,
// "name": "Eyewitness",
// "author": "elisa",
// "polina’s comments": "the disjuncts are of different kind (attribute vs. piece of clothing), not sure if that’s an issue. Also the disjunction is embedded under a complementizer.",
// "thoughts": "maybe exchange 'wore high heels' by 'is brunette'",
// "final comments": "disjuncts are predicates such that the questions with “both” might be a bit weird",
// "final_selection": 1,
// "type": "hll",
// "relevance": 1,
// "competence": 0,
// "prior": 0,
// "background": "Mrs Pruitt is questioned by the police about a lady she had seen this morning. Unfortunately, she can't give a full body description, since the lady stood behind a car and only her upper body was visible.",
// "utterance_or": "Mrs Pruitt reports to the police: 'I think she is very tall or wore high heels.'",
// "utterance_disj1": "Mrs Pruitt reports to the police: 'I think she is very tall.'",
// "utterance_disj2": "Mrs Pruitt reports to the police: 'I think she wore high heels.'",
// "question_rel": "It is important for the police to know whether the lady was both very tall and wore high heels.",
// "question_comp": "Mrs Pruitt knows whether the lady was both very tall and wore high heels.",
// "question_pri1": "If the lady was very tall, it is likely that she also wore high heels.",
// "question_pri2": "If the lady wore high heels, it is likely that she was also very tall.",
// "question_pri_and": "It is likely that the lady was both very tall and wore high heels.",
// "question_xor": "From what Mrs Pruitt said we may conclude that the lady was not both very tall and wore high heels.",
// "question_xorI": "Mrs Pruitt wants to convey that the lady was not both very tall and wore high heels.",
// "question_exh1": "From what Mrs Pruitt said we may conclude that the lady didn't wear high heels as well.",
// "question_exh2": "From what Mrs Pruitt said we may conclude that the lady wasn't very tall as well.",
// "test_true": "The police is looking for the lady that Mrs Pruitt saw.",
// "test_false": "Mrs Pruitt knows the lady very well.",
// "test_uncertain": "The lady is a suspect in a murder investigation.",
// "test_true1": "Mrs Pruitt is talking to the police.",
// "test_true2": "There is a crime suspect in Mrs Pruitt’s town.",
// "test_false1": "Mrs Pruitt is a crime suspect.",
// "test_false2": "Mrs Pruitt leads the investigation.",
// "test_uncertain1": "Mrs Pruitt is a teacher.",
// "test_uncertain2": "The lady was brunette."
// },
// {
// "ID": 36,
// "name": "College",
// "author": "neele",
// "polina’s comments": "the relevance depends a bit on the location of the hometown (i.e., if either of those colleges is close to home), or where she applied to college. The prior is not very salient but might be okay. I would also update the first comprehension question to “.. are friends” ",
// "thoughts": "Bob: Not sure about False1.",
// "final comments": "not sure about prior",
// "final_selection": 1,
// "type": "hll",
// "relevance": 1,
// "competence": 0,
// "prior": 0,
// "background": "Matthew and Alice got to know each other in high school and soon became friends. Now they finished high school and both of them want to go to college. Both of them have sent out some applications. Alice meets a neighbor of Matthew's family at the supermarket who tells her what he heard about Matthew’s applications.",
// "utterance_or": "The neighbor says to Alice: 'I heard Matthew got accepted to a college in Washington or Austin.'",
// "utterance_disj1": "The neighbor says to Alice: 'I heard Matthew got accepted to a college in Washington.'",
// "utterance_disj2": "The neighbor says to Alice: 'I heard Matthew got accepted to a college in Austin.'",
// "question_rel": "It is important for Alice to know whether Matthew got accepted to a college in both Washington and Austin.",
// "question_comp": "The neighbor knows whether Matthew got accepted to a college in both Washington and Austin.",
// "question_pri1": "If Matthew got accepted to a college in Washington, it is likely that he also got accepted to a college in Austin.",
// "question_pri2": "If Matthew got accepted to a college in Austin, it is likely that he also got accepted to a college in Washington.",
// "question_pri_and": "It is likely that Matthew got accepted to a college in both Washington and Austin.",
// "question_xor": "From what the neighbor said we may conclude that Matthew didn't get accepted to a college in both Austin and Washington.",
// "question_xorI": "The neighbor wants to convey that Matthew didn't get accepted to a college in both Austin and Washington.",
// "question_exh1": "From what the neighbor said we may conclude that Matthew didn't get accepted to a college in Austin as well.",
// "question_exh2": "From what the neighbor said we may conclude that Matthew didn't get accepted to a college in Washington as well.",
// "test_true": "Alice is shopping for groceries.",
// "test_false": "Henry and Alice are in kindergarden.",
// "test_uncertain": "Henry applied to Stanford university as well.",
// "test_true1": "Matthew and Alice like each other.",
// "test_true2": "Matthew and Alice finished high school.",
// "test_false1": "Matthew wants to become a carpenter.",
// "test_false2": "Alice didn't apply for a college.",
// "test_uncertain1": "Alice wants to study languages.",
// "test_uncertain2": "Alice likes Michael Jackson."
// }
],
hlh: [{
"ID": 2,
"name": "Brad's clothes",
"author": "micha",
"polina’s comments": "To me relevance doesn’t seem to be really high here, just as noted in previous comments. The prior might also not be clearly high to me: e.g. why didn’t he get new clothes earlier if the jokes bother him, maybe money issues etc? (rather a contextual prior here) ",
"thoughts": "Bob: Is the conjunction relevant? -> Micha: I thought yes, because just one piece of new clothing would not make him look much less shabby. -> Natalie: But then I think a mere two pieces of cloth aren't going to make it that much better either.",
"final comments": "still not sure about relevance here, but made some tweaks in the context",
"final_selection": 1,
"type": "hlh",
"relevance": 1,
"competence": 0,
"prior": 1,
"background": "Brad is notorious for his shabby clothes. His friends Gina and Mandy make frequent jokes about it, much to Brad's distress. Brad has a date next week, and Gina heard that he finally went shopping the other day.",
"utterance_or": "Gina tells Mandy: 'Brad bought a sweater or a pair of jeans.'",
"utterance_disj1": "Gina tells Mandy: 'Brad bought a sweater.'",
"utterance_disj2": "Gina tells Mandy: 'Brad bought a pair of jeans.'",
"question_rel": "It is important for Mandy to know whether Brad bought both a sweater and a pair of jeans.",
"question_comp": "Gina knows whether Brad bought both a sweater and a pair of jeans.",
"question_pri1": "If Brad bought a sweater, it is likely that he also bought a pair of jeans.",
"question_pri2": "If Brad bought a pair of jeans, it is likely that he also bought a sweater.",
"question_pri_and": "It is likely that Brad bought both a sweater and a pair of jeans. ",
"question_xor": "From what Gina said we may conclude that Brad did not buy both a sweater and a pair of jeans.",
"question_xorI": "Gina wants to convey that Brad did not buy both a sweater and a pair of jeans.",
"question_exh1": "From what Gina said we may conclude that Brad did not buy a pair of jeans as well.",
"question_exh2": "From what Gina said we may conclude that Brad did not buy a sweater as well.",
"test_true": "Brad is not happy about the fact that his friends make jokes about his shabby clothes.",
"test_false": "Gina and Mandy accompanied Brad on his shopping trip.",
"test_uncertain": "Mandy feels attracted to Brad.",
"test_true1": "Gina and Mandy care about Brad.",
"test_true2": "Brad spent money on clothes the other day.",
"test_false1": "Brad is a big fashion fan. ",
"test_false2": "Gina is Brad's sister.",
"test_uncertain1": "Gina, Mandy and Brad go to school together.",
"test_uncertain2": "Gina and Mandy have know each other since kindergarden."
},
// {
// "ID": 10,
// "name": "Gigi's exams",
// "author": "bob",
// "polina’s comments": "fine",
// "thoughts": "NA",
// "final comments": "not sure if there is a way to get rid of the conjunction in the background story",
// "final_selection": 1,
// "type": "hlh",
// "relevance": 1,
// "competence": 0,
// "prior": 1,
// "background": "Recently, Gigi took exams in Physics and Chemistry. She studied day and night and even paid for private tutoring. Carrie just heard some rumors from her fellow students when she talked to Gigi’s best friend.",
// "utterance_or": "Carrie tells Gigi's best friend: 'Gigi passed her Physics exam or her Chemistry exam.'",
// "utterance_disj1": "Carrie tells Gigi's best friend: 'Gigi passed her Physics exam.'",
// "utterance_disj2": "Carrie tells Gigi's best friend: 'Gigi passed her Chemistry exam.'",
// "question_rel": "It is important for Gigi's best friend to know whether Gigi passed both her Physics exam and her Chemistry exam.",
// "question_comp": "Carrie knows whether Gigi passed both her Physics exam and her Chemistry exam.",
// "question_pri1": "If Gigi passed her Physics exam, it is likely that she also passed her Chemistry exam.",
// "question_pri2": "If Gigi passed her Chemistry exam, it is likely that she also passed her Physics exam.",
// "question_pri_and": "It is likely that Gigi passed both her Physics and her Chemistry exams.",
// "question_xor": "From what Carrie said we may conclude that Gigi did not pass both her Physics exam and her Chemistry exam.",
// "question_xorI": "Carrie wants to convey that Gigi did not pass both her Physics exam and her Chemistry exam.",
// "question_exh1": "From what Carrie said we may conclude that Gigi did not pass her Chemistry exam as well.",
// "question_exh2": "From what Carrie said we may conclude that Gigi did not pass her Physics exam as well.",
// "test_true": "Gigi studied hard to pass her exams.",
// "test_false": "Gigi hired a private tutor to help her with her Biology and Chemistry exams.",
// "test_uncertain": "Gigi aspires to a career in science.",
// "test_true1": "Gigi took science exams.",
// "test_true2": "Carrie did not talk to Gigi about her exam results.",
// "test_false1": "Carrie is Gigi’s best friend.",
// "test_false2": "Carrie heard rumors that Gigi passed her Math exam.",
// "test_uncertain1": "Gigi’s best friend took a Physics exam, as well.",
// "test_uncertain2": "Gigi and her best friend want to go to the same college."
// },
// {
// "ID": 33,
// "name": "Rabbits",
// "author": "elisa",
// "polina’s comments": "the disjunction is embedded in a modal, Bob commented that that might be problematic. Also, it might just be me but it’s somehow weird that Tim arrives in the morning and James isn’t home YET..?",
// "thoughts": "NA",
// "final comments": "disjunction embedded under a model",
// "final_selection": 1,
// "type": "hlh",
// "relevance": 1,
// "competence": 0,
// "prior": 1,
// "background": "James has recently employed Tim, who is supposed to help him with small things in the household, like buying groceries. When Tim arrives this morning, James has already left for work. But his daughter Jessica remembers that her dad mentioned something about running out of food for their rabbits.",
// "utterance_or": "Jessica says to Tim: 'I think you should go out to buy carrots or apples.'",
// "utterance_disj1": "Jessica says to Tim: 'I think you should go out to buy carrots.'",
// "utterance_disj2": "Jessica says to Tim: 'I think you should go out to buy apples.'",
// "question_rel": "It is important for Tim to know whether he should buy both carrots and apples.",
// "question_comp": "Jessica knows whether Tim should buy both carrots and apples.",
// "question_pri1": "If Tim should buy carrots, it is likely that he should also buy apples.",
// "question_pri2": "If Tim should buy apples, it is likely that he should also buy carrots.",
// "question_pri_and": "It is likely that Tim should buy both apples and carrots.",
// "question_xor": "From what Jessica said we may conclude that Tim should not buy both carrots and apples.",
// "question_xorI": "Jessica wanted to convey that Tim should not buy both carrots and apples.",
// "question_exh1": "From what Jessica said we may conclude that Tim should not buy apples as well.",
// "question_exh2": "From what Jessica said we may conclude that Tim should not buy carrots as well.",
// "test_true": "Jessica and her father have more than one rabbit.",
// "test_false": "Jessica only lives with her mum.",
// "test_uncertain": "Tim was caught up in traffic jam.",
// "test_true1": "Tim’s job includes buying ingredients for Jessica’s lunch.",
// "test_true2": "Tim is James’ employee.",
// "test_false1": "Jessica’s family has no pets.",
// "test_false2": "Tim is Jessica’s brother.",
// "test_uncertain1": "Jessica has a cat as well.",
// "test_uncertain2": "James is a doctor."
// },
// {
// "ID": 37,
// "name": "Crime",
// "author": "neele",
// "polina’s comments": "is relevance really 1 here? Also “was” might be disadvantageous to an inclusive reading. Maybe the sentence could be something like “I heard that a crime involving.. happened”?",
// "thoughts": "MF: is the SAME event a robbery and an injury or are there two events; I massaged this into the former, but not sure this is what is best; what about 'I heard that'? Bob: Is a physical injury a type of crime? I'm not sure about Prior or Relevance.",
// "final comments": "not sure about relevance",
// "final_selection": 1,
// "type": "hlh",
// "relevance": 1,
// "competence": 0,
// "prior": 1,
// "background": "Lynn and Sally are on their way home. They've been partying together until early morning. Sally is telling Lynn about a crime incident that happened in Lynn's neighborhood last night, where violence and theft are frequent.",
// "utterance_or": "Sally says to Lynn: 'I heard that there was an incident involving an armed robbery or physical injury last night.'",
// "utterance_disj1": "Sally says to Lynn: 'I heard that there was an incident involving an armed robbery last night.'",
// "utterance_disj2": "Sally says to Lynn: 'I heard that there was an incident involving a physical injury last night.'",
// "question_rel": "It is important for Lynn to know whether the incident that happened last night involved both, an armed robbery and a physical injury.",
// "question_comp": "Sally knows whether the incident that happened last night involved both an armed robbery and a physical injury.",
// "question_pri1": "If the incident involved an armed robbery, it is likely that it also involved a physical injury.",
// "question_pri2": "If it the incident involved a physical injury, it is likely that it also involved an armed robbery.",
// "question_pri_and": "It is likely that the incident that happened last night involved both an armed robbery and a physical injury.",
// "question_xor": "From what Sally said we may conclude that the incident that happened last night didn’t involve both an armed robbery and a physical injury.",
// "question_xorI": "Sally wants to convey that the incident that happened last night didn’t involve both an armed robbery and a physical injury.",
// "question_exh1": "From what Sally said we may conclude that the incident didn’t involve an armed robbery as well.",
// "question_exh2": "From what Sally said we may conclude that the incident didn’t involve a physical injury as well.",
// "test_true": "Lynn lives in an insecure neighborhood.",
// "test_false": "Sally was at the cinema with her family last night.",
// "test_uncertain": "Sally and Lynn plan to go out again tonight.",
// "test_true1": "Sally and Lynn have been to a party.",
// "test_true2": "A crime was committed in Lynn’s neighborhood.",
// "test_false1": "Sally and Lynn are going home before midnight.",
// "test_false2": "Sally and Lynn don't like partying.",
// "test_uncertain1": "It's Sally's birthday.",
// "test_uncertain2": "Lynn has a dog."
// }
],
hhl: [{
"ID": 1,
"name": "Mrs Sanders' son",
"author": "micha",
"polina’s comments": "fine ",
"thoughts": "Bob: The verb 'reassured' suggests a non-conjunctive interpretation.",
"final comments": "NA",
"final_selection": 1,
"type": "hhl",
"relevance": 1,
"competence": 1,
"prior": 0,
"background": "During summer camp, every student was allowed at most one main dish for lunch, but some students queued up twice. Mrs Sanders was with her son Ted during the whole lunch break yesterday. A teacher approaches Mrs Sanders to find out how her son behaved during lunch.",
"utterance_or": "Mrs Sanders says to the teacher: 'Ted had pizza or pasta yesterday.'",
"utterance_disj1": "Mrs Sanders says to the teacher: 'Ted had pizza yesterday.'",
"utterance_disj2": "Mrs Sanders says to the teacher: 'Ted had pasta yesterday.'",
"question_rel": "It is important for the teacher to know whether Ted had both pizza and pasta yesterday.",
"question_comp": "Mrs Sanders knows whether Ted had both pizza and pasta yesterday.",
"question_pri1": "If Ted had pizza, it is likely that he also had pasta.",
"question_pri2": "If Ted had pasta, it is likely that he also had pizza.",
"question_pri_and": "It is likely that Ted had both pizza and pasta for lunch.",
"question_xor": "From what Mrs Sanders said we may conclude that Ted did not have both pizza and pasta.",
"question_xorI": "Mrs Sanders wants to convey that Ted did not have both pizza and pasta.",
"question_exh1": "From what Mrs Sanders said we may conclude that Ted did not have pasta as well.",
"question_exh2": "From what Mrs Sanders said we may conclude that Ted did not have pizza as well.",
"test_true": "The teacher is trying to find out who queued up twice.",
"test_false": "Ted is Mrs Sanders' husband.",
"test_uncertain": "Mrs Sanders had pasta for lunch yesterday.",
"test_true1": "Ted's last name is Sanders.",
"test_true2": "Mrs Sanders did not eat lunch at home yesterday.",
"test_false1": "The kids may have as many main courses as they want at the summer camp.",
"test_false2": "Mrs Sanders works at the summer camp cafeteria.",
"test_uncertain1": "Ted's father also visited him for lunch yesterday.",
"test_uncertain2": "Ted does not like pizza."
},
{
"ID": 9,
"name": "Pete's accident",
"author": "bob",
"polina’s comments": "minor, but I’m not sure about the competence: the teacher might not know the precise diagnosis yet?",
"thoughts": "NA",
"final comments": "NA",
"final_selection": 1,
"type": "hhl",
"relevance": 1,
"competence": 1,
"prior": 0,
"background": "Pete was playing on the schoolyard during lunch break when he fell off the slide. His teacher drove him to the hospital immediately and called Pete's mother from there as soon as he spoke to the doctor.",
"utterance_or": "The teacher told Pete's mother: 'Pete broke his arm or his leg.'",
"utterance_disj1": "The teacher told Pete's mother: 'Pete broke his arm.'",
"utterance_disj2": "The teacher told Pete's mother: 'Pete broke his leg.'",
"question_rel": "It is important for Pete's mother to know whether Pete broke both his arm and his leg when he fell off the slide.",
"question_comp": "The teacher knows whether Pete broke both his arm and his leg when he fell off the slide.",
"question_pri1": "If Pete broke his arm, it is likely that he also broke his leg when he fell off the slide.",
"question_pri2": "If Pete broke his leg, it is likely that he also broke his arm when he fell off the slide.",
"question_pri_and": "It is likely that Pete broke both his arm and his leg when he fell off the slide.",
"question_xor": "From what Pete's teacher said we may conclude that Pete did not break both his arm and his leg.",
"question_xorI": "Pete's teacher wanted to convey that Pete did not break both his arm and his leg.",
"question_exh1": "From what Pete's teacher said we may conclude that Pete did not break his leg as well.",
"question_exh2": "From what Pete's teacher said we may conclude that Pete did not break his arm as well.",
"test_true": "Pete's mother was not there when he fell of the slide.",
"test_false": "Pete was injured while playing in the garden.",
"test_uncertain": "Pete's teacher saw him fall off the slide.",
"test_true1": "Pete’s mother received a call from the hospital. ",
"test_true2": "Pete had an accident.",
"test_false1": "Pete’s father called Pete’s mother to tell her about the injury.",
"test_false2": "Pete is a college student.",
"test_uncertain1": "Pete’s friends were on the slide, too.",
"test_uncertain2": "Pete’s mother works as a waitress."
},
{
"ID": 18,
"name": "Frank's laptop",
"author": "natalie",
"polina’s comments": "the singular “is” might suggest an exclusive reading? I also agree that the competence is not very clear. I also think that the relevance would be more salient if the hearer would be Frank himself. Maybe this could be a high-relevance & high-competence item if the speaker would be the repair service technician? Again, the consequence of the prior questions should probably not be negated?",
"thoughts": "Bob: probably should be clearer that Frank is incompetent. Also unsure about prior.",
"final comments": "singular “is” in the xor utterance might suggest an exclusive reading",
"final_selection": 1,
"type": "hhl",
"relevance": 1,
"competence": 1,
"prior": 0,
"background": "Frank's laptop is in repair. He is worried because he needs it back as soon as possible to finish his assignment for school. Frank calls the repair service and asks the technician what the problem is.",
"utterance_or": "The technician says to Frank: 'The hard drive or the battery is broken.'",
"utterance_disj1": "The technician says to Frank: 'The hard drive is broken.'",
"utterance_disj2": "The technician says to Frank: 'The battery is broken.'",
"question_rel": "It is important for Frank to know whether both the hard drive and the battery are broken.",
"question_comp": "The technician knows whether both the hard drive and the battery are broken.",
"question_pri1": "If the hard drive is broken, it is likely that the battery is broken as well.",
"question_pri2": "If the battery is broken, it is likely that the hard drive is broken as well.",
"question_pri_and": "It is likely that both the battery and the hard drive are broken.",
"question_xor": "From what the technician said we may conclude that not both the hard drive and the battery are broken.",
"question_xorI": "The technician wants to convey that not both the hard drive and the battery are broken.",
"question_exh1": "From what the technician said we may conclude that the battery is not broken as well.",
"question_exh2": "From what the technician said we may conclude that the hard drive is not broken as well.",
"test_true": "The laptop is Frank's.",
"test_false": "Frank gave his computer to a friend for repair.",
"test_uncertain": "The laptop is very old.",
"test_true1": "Frank needs his laptop back as soon as possible.",
"test_true2": "There is computer repair service in Frank’s town. ",
"test_false1": "Frank’s desktop computer is in repair.",
"test_false2": "Frank repairs his laptop himself.",
"test_uncertain1": "Frank wants to buy a new computer.",
"test_uncertain2": "Frank’s laptop is in repair because he spilled coffee all over it. "
},
{
"ID": 35,
"name": "Crush",
"author": "neele",
"polina’s comments": "the relevance question is missing the second disjunct.",
"thoughts": "Bob: The question for Rel is wrong. It's probably impossible to ask the Competence question without the utterance.",
"final comments": "NA",
"final_selection": 1,
"type": "hhl",
"relevance": 1,
"competence": 1,
"prior": 0,
"background": "Henry fell in love with Anna, a girl he met in a Chinese course, but he is afraid Anna might have a crush on Brad instead. After the Chinese class he walks home with Anna's best friend Jenny and tries to find out how Anna feels about him.",
"utterance_or": "Jenny tells Henry: 'Anna has a crush on you or Brad.'",
"utterance_disj1": "Jenny tells Henry: 'Anna has a crush on you.'",
"utterance_disj2": "Jenny tells Henry: 'Anna has a crush on Brad.'",
"question_rel": "It is important for Henry to know whether Anna has a crush on both, him and Brad.",
"question_comp": "Jenny knows whether Anna has a crush on both, Henry and Brad.",
"question_pri1": "If Anna has a crush on Henry, it is likely that she also has a crush on Brad.",
"question_pri2": "If Anna has a crush on Brad, it is likely that she also has a crush on Henry.",
"question_pri_and": "It is likely that Anna has a crush on both, Henry and Brad.",
"question_xor": "From what Jenny said we may conclude that Anna doesn't have a crush on both, Henry and Brad.",
"question_xorI": "Jenny wants to convey that Anna doesn't have a crush on both, Henry and Brad.",
"question_exh1": "From what Jenny said we may conclude that Anna doesn't have a crush on Henry as well.",
"question_exh2": "From what Jenny said we may conclude that Anna doesn't have a crush on Brad as well.",
"test_true": "Jenny is the best friend of Henry’s crush.",
"test_false": "Henry is in love with Jenny.",
"test_uncertain": "Henry and Anna take a math class together, as well.",
"test_true1": "Henry and Anna are taking a Chinese course.",
"test_true2": "Jenny walks home with Henry.",
"test_false1": "Jenny and Henry are going home by car.",
"test_false2": "Henry knows Anna from a Swedish course",
"test_uncertain1": "Jenny has a crush on Sam.",
"test_uncertain2": "Jenny speaks Swedish."
}],
hhh: [{
"ID": 0,
"name": "Mrs Gibbs' worry",
"author": "micha",
"polina’s comments": "fine",
"thoughts": "NA",
"final comments": "NA",
"final_selection": 1,
"type": "hhh",